Sweet as pie: Anna Mae Wagler remembered for kindness, determination and delicious food

She was the founder of the popular Anna Mae’s Restaurant and Bakery, and a person who loved her family and cared for others.

That’s how Amanda Herrford describes her late friend Anna Mae Wagler, who passed away, age 74, on March 26 after a battle with cancer.

According to Wagler’s obituary, she began her baking business in 1978 by making pies in her home and selling them near her laneway.

“In 1991, she moved to the location we’re at now. She had a vision and she was a strong and determined woman,” said Herrford.

“Many people told her when she moved into this location that it would not work, it would not be busy, this would never fly in a small town, and she went ahead anyways and proved everybody wrong.”

She said Wagler, a local Mennonite, helped put Millbank on the map through the restaurant, resulting in several businesses booming in the town, including furniture, hardware and thrift stores, Zehrs country market, equipment places and Elizabeth Watson Floral and Artisan shop.

Herrford’s parents bought the restaurant from Wagler in 2001, leading her to start working there and getting a chance to meet Anna Mae.

The menu has expanded to include wholesome, hearty meals in addition to the always popular fresh breads and desserts.

“Every time she was in here, we would always chat, she would come for meals, she would come and get baking and pie dough, if I had any questions I (could) always call and ask her,” said Herrford.

She wants Wagler to be remembered as a hard-worker, humble and caring person with a fun sense of humour.

Hussam Elghussein
Hussam Elghussein
Hussam is a reporter with Vista Radio, where he has been covering a wide range of stories — from local accidents to provincial announcements — since late 2022. Originally from London, Ont., he is also passionate about video games, film, and theatre.

Continue Reading

cjcs Now playing play

chgk Now playing play

- Advertisement -

Related Articles

- Advertisement -

Latest News

De Havilland Canada reaches $2.5B financing deal to double waterbomber production

De Havilland Canada has reached an agreement with the federal government and Export Development Canada (EDC) for up to $2.5 billion in financing to double production capacity for its Canadair 515 waterbombers.

Stratford filled with events celebrating Halloween

Multiple events are scheduled from Friday to Sunday for the spookiest time of the year.

No injuries reported after recent North Perth barn fire

Perth County OPP and the North Perth Fire Department responded to the fire Wednesday on Perth Line 88 near Gowanstown.

Perth OPP looking for missing Milverton man

Police said they received a report on Thursday that William Westman was last seen at his Milverton home on 9:30 a.m. that day.

GOHL: Pair of road games this weekend for Stratford Warriors

Sarnia Legionnaires won their first game since February, 2025 on Thursday when they beat St. Thomas Stars 4-1.
- Advertisement -